Link to the original article
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/06/opinion/sunday/why-black-women-are-fat.html
—————————————————–
Once again, Black women have found another reason to sigh. The original NY Times article titled “Why Black Women are Fat” (which was later changed to Black and Fat) is one woman’s perception on why Black women are statistically more obese than white women.
The author of the piece, Alice Randall (yes, she’s black, put away the stones) said “Because too many experts who are involved in the discussion of obesity don’t understand something crucial about black women and fat: many black women are fat because we want to be.”
Her articles goes forth to explain black women (and their men) find the fatter size to be more appealing and as a result choose to stay fat. She encourages Black women to get under 200lbs and to eat healthier and live a better, more active lifestyle.
All of that is perfectly valid. People should be out exercising, eating healthy, and not morbidly obese.
However, the sweeping generalization of black women is what brings about the sigh.
My issue is that she doesn’t address a lingering factor of obesity – the mental compulsion that drives someone to eat. It’s anorexia in reverse. Seeing as our community only believes in God and the Devil it’s no wonder that the mental health issues surrounding obesity in the Black community go unnoticed.
I have never once met a bigger person who was big because they “wanted to be.” What I have met are bigger people who eat emotionally and compulsively. I’ve met bigger people that accept their fate to be big and are not fat because they “want to be” but fat because they feel they have to be fat.
Randall does have a point that our society accepts and encouraged curvy black women with little waist lines that may be pounds heavier than the obesity index says she should be. HOWEVER, some of us will never get to the obesity index’s perfect level.
What if I told you I was overweight? According to the BMI index. At 170lbs and 5 foot 5 inches I’m very overweight. And yes that’s a recent picture.
At this same weight, I’ve done more exercise than I have in my entire life and I’m more conscious of what I eat daily. So I should desire to not be “fat” according to the scale?
Another point that Randall is missing is that skinny people have heart attacks too. I know skinny women that haven’t run for anything other than a shoe sale. Skinny or smaller doesn’t equal being healthy and we should ALL be striving for healthier choices and more exercise – regardless of size. Focusing on size alone will only lead to our continued body image issues and completely leave off the most important thing – overall good health.
The article should have addressed the overall eating habits of women of color and not just their size and weight. We all know Jennifer Hudson showed us it was possible to become a size two and sing to yourself on a commercial, but that will NOT be every woman’s story. No matter how much weight she has lost, Jennifer is still “curvy” by the model standards. BUT she is healthy now.
We need to push health in our community – not hitting a number on a scale or a pants size. Articles like this one encourage body image issues in black women to get to a certain size and shape but completely bypass overall health. Size is not sole the determining factor in how healthy someone is or is not.
Our communities can be food deserts without access to fresh fruits and vegetables, but a KFC on every corner. In that statistic about black women and obesity, is poverty even considered? Or are we all just fat because we want to be, not because we have no choice but to eat what is available?
Most importantly, black women are tired of being white America’s science experiment. Last time I checked, Paula Deen had diabetes and it’s because she was eating fried butter on a stick dipped in sugar. Seriously, who still cooks with that much lard? American’s as a whole are unhealthy, sometimes lazy, and the product of convenient, terrible food. I completely understand leading the charge to bring curvy women into good health and fight the health problems that rage in our community – but focusing 3/4th of an article on SIZE isn’t the way to go about creating that change.
I wish the article had done more to encourage our community rather than damn them to diabetes hell or a perpetual cycle of body image issues.
I’m healthy. My heart is working fine. My blood work is superb.
And my booty and hips are huge.
I’m a “fat” black woman who is healthy and happy.
It’s quite possible….no matter the size on the pants or the number on the scale.

